Comparison Figure 1: my score 34, alex score 36, +2-
my scoring with Alex standard score deviant 2 points in group 5
which is i am observing that both eyes filled in lines (/b), and only one eyebrows, no pupils, no eyelash, no eyeglasses or even eyeball (/c), thus, i am giving 3 marks. all the others' point remain exactly same with the standard scoring.
if looking details at the picture 1, the right eyes have one eyes brow, but not left
the shape of nose consider as eyebrow?
the others' differences with others' ALS members is in categories
2: attachment, differ with 2 ALS member
3: clothing, differ with 1 ALS member
5: eyes, differ with 3 ALS member
10: legs, differ with 2 ALS member
11: mouth, differ with 2 ALS member
12: neck, differ with 1 ALS member
14: trunk, differ with2 ALS member
the similarities of scoring is for categories (1) arm, (4) ears, (6) feet, (7) fingers, and (13) nose.
i am glad that we have the similarities and the inter-scoring is not too big gap at all.
～ * ～ * ～ * ～ * ～ * ～ * ～ * ～ * ～ * ～ * ～ * ～ * ～ * ～
Comparison Figure 2: my score 24, alex score24, +0-
my scoring with Alex standard score remain same, but there is few categories we have different remarks, which is categories (5) eyes, (10) legs, and (13) nose.
category (5) EYES
i am observing that Eyes present (a), both eyes filled in circles (b), have pupils (c), no proportion (/d), as (/d) not given, no bonus given (/e)
but Alex scoring is Eyes present (a), both eyes not in two dimensions (/b),no details (/c), no proportion : both ayes not wider than high (/d), no bonus (/e)
For the eyes scoring, i am still not sure, how to define it. When i looking at the picture, i think eyes with 2 dimensional, with both eyes filled in circles. Does it means it must be have exactly the eyes shape? the eyes of HFD 2 is wider and bigger. Besides, when i look at the eyes, seems like there is a "dot" and looks like pupils, thus i put (c)
category (10) LEGS
i am observing that Legs present (a), no detail (/b), no proportion (/c), no bonus (/d) but Alex scoring is Legs present (a), no detail (/b), longer than wide (c), no bonus (/d)
i admit that when i looks back and check, both legs is longer than wide, i had missed out this point of details category (13) NOSE
i am observing that Nose present (a), nostrils bridge of nose no detail (/b), no proportion (/c), as (/b) to (/c) not credited, no bonus (/d) but Alex scoring is Nose present (a), nostrils given (b), nose not longer than wide (/c), no bonus (/d)
Trying to check the nostrils. So, i learn that any shape of nose can be given a point. the others' differences with others' ALS members in categories
1: arm, differ with 2 ALS member
3: clothing, differ with 5 ALS member
5: eyes, differ with 3 ALS member
6: feets, differ with 3 ALS member
7: fingers, differ with 1 ALS member
10: legs, differ with 4 ALS member
13: nose, differ with 2 ALS member
14: trunk, differ with 1 ALS member the similarities of scoring is for categories (2) attachement, (4) ears, (8) hair, (9) head, (7) fingers, and (11) mouth, (12) neck
the overall scoring for figure 2 is about 9 points, the highest scoring is 33, the lowest is 24
～ * ～ * ～ * ～ * ～ * ～ * ～ * ～ * ～ * ～ * ～ * ～ * ～ * ～
Comparison Figure 3: my score 40, alex score43, +3-
my scoring with Alex standard score different in 3 points, but different remarks in fews categories, which is categories (2) attachment, (7) fingers, (8) hairs, (10) legs, (11) mouth, and (14) trunk.
category (2) ATTACHMENT
i am observing that ..... arms and legs at appropriate places (d) bonus as (a) through (d) correct.
but Alex scoring is ..........arm not attached at appropriate places (/d), no bonus (/e)
I think, the distance of arm to shoulder is make a little bit confusion, all ALS members put 5 points as mine scoring too....... haha...looks like all of us miss/overlooked this little part. Well, try to improve the observation skills and rating skills
category (7) FINGERS
i am observing that ..... Image of fingers present (a), no complete five fingers on either hand (/b) and on both hands (/c), no thumb (/d), not all fingers with length and width (/e), no proportion (/f), as only (a) credited, no bonus (/g)
but Alex scoring is different. His comments for this part is Fingers present (a), no five fingers on either hand (/b) not on both hands (/c), no thumb (/d), two dimensional (e) length greater than width in more than half of fingers (f), as only (a) (e) (f) credited, no bonus (/g)
My tiny mistake on 2 dimensional and length greater than width. will try to be more careful....
there is One ALS members having the same score as mine
category (8) HAIR
i am observing that Hair present (a), hair on top and left side of head (b), no style or detail (/c), no bonus(/d) as (/c) not credited
but Alex scoring is Hair present (a), more than on top of head (b）， distinct Ghainaian style (c) bonus (/e)
I thought this one not considering as hairstyle.... so, i didn't give any points to the HAIR detail/style thun, no bonus. well, interestingly there is 2 ALS members have same scoring as mine. haha.... OK, i can accept this as "Distinct Ghainaian Hair Style", will try to be details and cautious about the proportion/remarks
category (10) LEGS
i am observing that Legs present (a), detail with break between pant and foot (b), no proportion (/c), no bonus (/d) because lack of (/c) but Alex scoring and comment is a bit different from mine: Legs present (a), crotch: legs meet at point below trunk (b), longer than wide (c), as (a) to (c) credited bonus (d)
i admit i had missed the point of details, still the drawing seems a little bit tricky for me category (11) MOUTH
i am observing that Mouth present (a),with two dimensions - open (b), no proportion (/c), no bonus (/d) as criteria (/c) not present but Alex scoring and comment is a bit different from mine: mouth present (a), two dimensional (b), horizontal greater than vertical (c), as (a) to (c) credited bonus (d)
i missed out this. almost all of the ALS is having same perceptions as mine, i did not aware of the horizontal greater than vertical category (14) TRUNK
i am observing that Trunk present (a), bigger shoulder (b), trunk length shorter than width (c), bonus given (d)but Alex scoring is Trunk present (a), no waist (/b), not longer than wide (/c), as only (a) credited, no bonus (/d)
the others' differences with others' ALS members in categories
1: arm, differ with 2 ALS member
3: clothing, differ with 5 ALS member
5: eyes, differ with 3 ALS member
6: feet, differ with 3 ALS member
7: fingers, differ with 1 ALS member
10: legs, differ with 4 ALS member
13: nose, differ with 2 ALS member
14: trunk, differ with 1 ALS member the similarities of scoring is for categories (2) attachement, (4) ears, (8) hair, (9) head, (7) fingers, and (11) mouth, (12) neck
the overall scoring for figure 2 is about 9 points, the highest scoring is 33, the lowest is 24
hmmm..........
i am trying to check detail one by one and giving score with neutral and open minded
but still, there is some piece i had missed out
but good to have a different showing on this part.
at least, i am aware of how the perception is similar and diverse off
gotta continue to do my next exercise........
will continue one by one
No comments:
Post a Comment